I was looking for a new wool coat since my last one was purchased over 10 years ago. When it comes to the style and look of this coat, as well of the material, I would give it 5-stars. However, there are a few drawbacks that caused me to knock it down to 4-stars.First, as said in other reviews, the bib is not removable. I didn't think it would be an issue, but it does take some getting used to.Second, the sizing guide is off, so you will likely want to order a size larger than the guide suggests. The guide told me to get a small. I generally wear either a medium or large in most things, so I went ahead and ordered the medium.Third, I lift / exercise a lot so I have a fit / athletic build. I often buy fitted clothes that taper in around the waist. The jacket I ordered has perfect arm length but fits a little snug in the shoulders, chest and arms. Not only that, but if I had ordered a size larger it would likely balloon out far too much in the waist. This means I can't wear it with a heavy sweater, but I guess the bib I complained about earlier minimizes the need for a sweater.Other than those 3 complaints it is a very nice, well priced jacket.I'm 5'11, 170 pounds, 10% body fat. I have a 42.5 inch chest, 36 inch waist, 35.5 arm length.Jean size is 31 waist / 34 leg and dress shirt size is a fitted Large which is usually a 16 neck / 42 chest